Homer Simpson vs Peter Griffin

[Voorheeszilla]

Two fat, idiotic bastards go at it, who wins?

http://www.freewebs.com/kalebreel/HomerSimpson49.gif

http://starsmedia.ign.com/stars/image/article/890/890465/top-10-family-guy-characters-feature-20080716024222109-000.jpg

My money is on my main man, Homer.

[Evil_Meanie]

Homer. He's been around for 20 years and hasn't annoyed me yet. Peter Griffin on the other hand...

[Kat]

Homer all the way...
JTT--MhbgQU

[Jus-X]

I think the real challenge would be Maggie vs Stewie.

[girlychaos]

I love Stewie. :p

As for this poll, I'll probably go with Homer, but I need to give it a little more thought.

[Voorheeszilla]

I was almost tempted to give the edge to Peter based on how many fights he's been in.

[Kat]

I was almost tempted to give the edge to Peter based on how many fights he's been in.

But Homer has been shot in the gut with cannon balls and damn near won the heavyweight championship... remember when Moe was his boxing manager? Peter's only notable epic fights were with that giant chicken.

[Voorheeszilla]

Homer has been through a lot, but c'mon, it takes a lot of balls for someone to go head up with a giant chicken. :p But Homer technically only won the heavyweight championship because he'd stand there and take punishment until the other boxer tired himself out. So, I guess Homer would have to have a better damage soak than Peter.

[Kat]

Peter would just get tired and give up. He is like he has ADD, have you even seen how that show cuts from one scene to another :p

[Evil_Meanie]

I'm sure that the heavyweight boxing champion of the world would have no problem taking down a giant chicken, though.

He had all sorts of problems taking down Homer.

And Peter, in turn, seem to have a bit of problem taking down the chicken.

So using that logic, Homer must win.

[Voorheeszilla]

Well, it IS a giant chicken afterall, lol. So, I can fathom him having trouble taking it down, but still, Peter is a pretty good fighter from what I can gather.

And while we're at it, why is it that when Homer tries fighting a bad guy the damage he deals rarely is enough to put them down or effect them? :lol:

[The Taff]

Homer Simpson. I don't need a reason.

[Darth Reaper]

Of course you guys realize that Al Bundy would kick both of their candyasses right? Of course, he'd then get his feet stuck in the flab and be crippled for life, but that's life as a Bundy for ya. :D

[jasonlives13]

Peter Griffin, im tired of the simpsons.

[The Tall Man]

In the interest of fairness:

*ahem*

Homer Simpson, I'm tired of "Family Guy"... and have been for a LONG time.

T.M., Esq.

[Boiler Room Brawler]

Since this isn't a popularity contest, I'm going to pick Peter Griffin.

Homer can take a beating but it's clear from watching Peter fight the Giant Chicken that he has stamina out the ass; enough to continue conversations afterwards without missing a beat.

[The Tall Man]

it's clear from watching Peter fight the Giant Chicken that he has stamina out the ass
That's not what Lois told me...

T.M., Esq.

[Boiler Room Brawler]

That's not what Lois told me...

T.M., Esq.
Yeah, but we already know that Lois can kick his ass with martial arts.

So maybe the real fight should be Lois Griffin versus Homer. :D

[The Tall Man]

I don't think that was her meaning. ;)

T.M., Esq.

[Rich]

The Simpsons have been on TV a lot longer then Family Guy, but I like Family Guy a lot more. I like Peter Griffen. He is funny. I choose him.

[Bill 1981]

I think the real challenge would be Maggie vs Stewie.

Maggie would gut Stewie with a broken bottle. :doggy:

EDIT: I have photographic proof that Maggie can be a badass.

http://www.americancitizenstogether.org/ACT/Pictures/Maggie_Simpson.jpg

[The Dude]

Homer! Family Guy just isnt funny to me anymore. Maybe it's because its on all the time, or maybe its because they're just all about shock value as opposed to being clever. Either way i'm all Simpsons!
ADDED:
Homer all the way...
JTT--MhbgQU

that....was..... AWESOME!!!!

[Jus-X]

Maggie would gut Stewie with a broken bottle. :doggy:

EDIT: I have photographic proof that Maggie can be a badass.

http://www.americancitizenstogether.org/ACT/Pictures/Maggie_Simpson.jpg

lol Great scene. :lol:

But Stewie has been known to use guns and bats. Remember when Brian woudn't pay Stewie back?

iFfzH2W2w4g

Where's my money?

[Voorheeszilla]

Stewie can be a badass when he wants to be.